Theft and robbery charges can come from moments of poor judgment, addiction struggles, or even misunderstandings that escalate quickly. Unlike simple mistakes, these cases create immediate consequences like arrest records, job risks, and family stress, plus potential jail time and long-term criminal records. Foglia & Associates helps people in Framingham and MetroWest (Worcester, Milford, Natick, Marlborough) fight these charges with clear strategies focused on real outcomes.
Need help with theft or robbery charges? Schedule a Consultation
What counts as theft (larceny) versus robbery in Massachusetts?
Theft, or larceny, involves taking someone else’s property with intent to keep it permanently. This covers shoplifting, employee theft, pickpocketing, and stealing from cars or homes. Massachusetts splits larceny into misdemeanor (under $250, up to 1 year jail/$1,500 fine) and felony (over $250, up to 5 years prison/$25,000 fine), with even harsher penalties for firearms, motor vehicles (15 years), or theft from elderly/disabled victims.
Robbery takes theft to a more serious level by adding force, threats, or intimidation to steal property directly from a person. Unarmed robbery carries state prison time up to life, while armed robbery (weapon involved) mandates minimums starting at 5 years with maximum life sentences. The key difference: simple theft targets property, robbery targets people with violence or fear.
Facing theft accusations? Get legal help before your first court date.
Since 1993
Bilingual Customer Service (PT / ES / EN / HE / RO)
Personal Injury and Criminal Defense Lawyers
How do police investigate and charge theft and robbery cases in Massachusetts?
Theft cases often start with store security footage, employee reports, or neighbors spotting suspicious activity near cars or homes. Shoplifting triggers immediate civil demands for payment plus criminal charges, while larger thefts bring detective investigations with surveillance review, witness interviews, and pawn shop records. Police build cases around “specific intent”, proving you planned to permanently deprive the owner.
Robbery investigations escalate quickly with victim statements, 911 calls, and descriptions of clothing/weapons creating immediate suspect sketches circulated to patrols. Street robberies often involve multiple officers canvassing areas, reviewing ATM/business cameras, and pulling phone location data with warrants. Both charge types rely heavily on witness identification, which defense teams challenge through inconsistencies, lighting conditions, and stress factors during the incident.
Arrested for robbery? Talk to our lawyer immediately.
What are the real penalties and consequences beyond jail time?
Larceny convictions create criminal records affecting jobs, apartments, loans, and professional licenses, with felonies (over $250) carrying 5-year potential prison sentences and $25,000 fines. Shoplifting adds civil penalties of $50-$500 per incident plus store bans, while repeat theft offenders face “common and notorious thief” labels with up to 20 years exposure.
Robbery penalties dwarf theft: unarmed carries any term up to life in state prison, armed mandates 5-15 year minimums, and elderly/disabled victims trigger even longer sentences. Beyond bars, robbery survivors often pursue civil lawsuits, and convictions destroy firearm rights, federal employment eligibility, and immigration status while haunting CORI/background checks forever.
Worried about job loss from theft charges? Learn your defense options today.
Common defenses and strategies for theft and robbery cases
Many theft cases hinge on shaky evidence: mistaken identity from blurry security footage, lack of proof you intended to permanently deprive the owner, or claims of “borrowing” rather than stealing. Defense teams attack chain of custody (who handled evidence), store policies violating rights, and overcharging (petty vs felony value disputes). First-time shoplifters often qualify for diversion programs avoiding convictions entirely.
Robbery defenses focus on lack of force/threat (no robbery without intimidation), identity challenges (single witness under stress), and self-defense claims in physical confrontations. Motions suppress illegally obtained evidence (warrantless phone dumps, coerced statements) while negotiating charge reductions to assault/battery or simple larceny when facts support it. Early restitution offers can sway prosecutors toward probation over prison.
First-time theft charge? Explore your options now.
Since 1993
Bilingual Customer Service (PT / ES / EN / HE / RO)
Personal Injury and Criminal Defense Lawyers
Theft and Robbery FAQ (Massachusetts) – 10 Questions
1. What is the difference between shoplifting and larceny in Massachusetts?
Shoplifting is a specific larceny type involving stores/merchants, carrying both criminal charges (jail/fines) and civil penalties ($50-$500). All shoplifting is larceny, but larceny covers broader theft.
2. Can a first-time shoplifting charge get dismissed?
Yes, first offenses under $250 often qualify for diversion programs, pre-trial probation, or continuance-without-finding leading to dismissal upon completion.
3. What happens if I’m caught stealing a car in Massachusetts?
Larceny of a motor vehicle carries up to 15 years state prison/$15,000 fine. Repeat convictions mandate 1-year minimum jail. Joyriding (no intent to keep) carries lesser penalties.
4. Does employee theft get treated differently than stranger theft?
Yes, employers often pursue felony embezzlement charges regardless of amount, plus civil lawsuits for restitution. Internal cameras/statements strengthen prosecution cases.
5. Can police search my phone after a theft arrest?
Only with warrant, consent, or incident-to-arrest limits. Defense challenges overbroad warrants extracting unrelated data.
6. What is “unarmed robbery” and how serious is it?
Taking property through force/threats without weapons. Punishable by state prison up to life, same severity bracket as armed robbery.
7. Can I get probation instead of jail for felony theft?
Often yes, especially first offenses with restitution, community service, and counseling. Judges consider employment/family ties favorably.
8. Do theft convictions affect gun rights or citizenship?
Yes, felony thefts destroy firearm eligibility. Non-citizens face deportation/removal proceedings.
9. What evidence do prosecutors need for a robbery conviction?
Victim testimony of force/threats, property taken, identification. Defense attacks shaky IDs, consent claims, lack of fear proof.
10. How long do theft cases typically take in Massachusetts courts?
3-12 months. Simple shoplifting: 2-4 months. Felony theft/robbery: 6-18 months with motions/trial prep.
